The Smith & Wesson Model 686 is a legendary revolver, renowned for its reliability, accuracy, and robust build. But it's not the only game in town. Many excellent revolvers compete with the 686, offering similar features or unique advantages depending on your needs and budget. This guide explores some of the top Smith & Wesson 686 competitors, helping you find the perfect wheelgun for your shooting style and purpose.
Key Features of the Smith & Wesson 686
Before diving into the competition, let's quickly recap what makes the 686 so popular. Key features often cited include:
- .357 Magnum/.38 Special Caliber: The versatility of handling both powerful magnum rounds and milder .38 Special cartridges is a significant draw.
- 7-Shot Capacity: A substantial capacity for a revolver, offering greater firepower than many competitors.
- Durable Construction: Known for its ruggedness and ability to withstand heavy use.
- Accuracy: The 686 consistently delivers impressive accuracy, making it suitable for target shooting and hunting.
Top Smith & Wesson 686 Competitors
Several manufacturers produce revolvers that directly compete with the 686, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. Here are some prominent contenders:
Ruger GP100
The Ruger GP100 is a frequent comparison point for the 686. It's known for its:
- Rugged Reliability: Ruger revolvers are built like tanks, known for their ability to handle significant recoil and withstand harsh conditions.
- Variety of Configurations: Available in different barrel lengths, finishes, and even in .22LR, offering more customization options than the 686.
- Generally Lower Price Point: Often more affordable than the S&W 686, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious shooters.
Where it differs: The GP100's trigger pull is generally considered heavier than the 686's, and some users find its grip less ergonomic.
Taurus 686 (and other Taurus models)
Taurus offers several revolvers that are visually and functionally similar to the Smith & Wesson 686. These are often significantly less expensive.
Considerations: While affordable, Taurus revolvers have sometimes been criticized for inconsistent quality control. Thorough research and careful inspection before purchase are crucial.
Colt Python (and other Colt revolvers)
The Colt Python is a legendary revolver in its own right, though it often commands a premium price due to its history and craftsmanship.
Key Differences: The Python offers a smoother, more refined action than the 686, but this often comes at a significantly higher price point. Colt also offers other models that compete directly with the 686 in terms of features and price.
Charter Arms Bulldog
For those seeking a smaller and more compact option, the Charter Arms Bulldog is a worthy contender. This revolver is lighter and more easily concealed than the 686.
Trade-offs: The Bulldog typically sacrifices some capacity and power for its reduced size and weight.
Choosing the Right Revolver
Selecting the right revolver depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences. Consider these factors:
- Budget: Prices vary significantly among these models.
- Intended Use: Target shooting, hunting, self-defense, or concealed carry all influence your choice.
- Caliber Preference: .357 Magnum offers versatility, but other calibers might better suit your needs.
- Ergonomics: Handle comfort and grip size are crucial for comfortable shooting.
- Reliability: Research each model's reputation for reliability and durability.
Ultimately, the "best" competitor to the Smith & Wesson 686 is subjective. Careful consideration of your priorities and a thorough examination of the available options will help you find the perfect revolver to meet your requirements. Remember to always handle firearms safely and responsibly.
