Choosing a concealed carry revolver can be a daunting task, especially with so many excellent options available. Two models consistently top the lists for many: the Ruger LCR and the Smith & Wesson 642. Both are lightweight, reliable, and chambered in .38 Special, but subtle differences make one a better fit for certain individuals than the other. This detailed comparison will help you decide which revolver best meets your needs.
Key Differences: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Both the Ruger LCR and the Smith & Wesson 642 are popular choices for personal defense, offering similar features but with distinct characteristics. Let's delve into the crucial aspects:
1. Weight and Feel:
- Ruger LCR: Known for its incredibly lightweight design thanks to its polymer frame and lightweight components. This makes it extremely comfortable to carry concealed all day, but some find the lighter weight contributes to more felt recoil.
- Smith & Wesson 642: Slightly heavier than the LCR due to its all-steel construction. This added weight reduces felt recoil, leading to potentially improved accuracy, especially for those new to revolvers. However, it can be a bit more noticeable when carried concealed.
2. Recoil:
- Ruger LCR: The lighter weight translates to more felt recoil. This can be a significant factor for shooters with smaller hands or those sensitive to recoil. While manageable, it's something to consider during practice and self-defense scenarios.
- Smith & Wesson 642: The heavier weight absorbs recoil more effectively, resulting in a gentler shooting experience. This is beneficial for both accuracy and comfort, particularly during extended shooting sessions.
3. Trigger Pull:
- Ruger LCR: The LCR's trigger pull is generally described as having a slightly harder, crisper pull. While this can contribute to safety, some shooters might find it less comfortable than the 642's trigger.
- Smith & Wesson 642: The 642 often boasts a slightly smoother, lighter trigger pull. This can contribute to faster target acquisition and potentially improved accuracy for experienced shooters. However, a lighter trigger can also be a concern for safety if not handled properly.
4. Grip:
- Ruger LCR: The LCR's grip is typically made of rubber, which provides a firm grip even in wet conditions. The design is often praised for its comfort and control. However, it may feel slightly smaller than that of the 642 for those with larger hands.
- Smith & Wesson 642: The 642's grip is generally made of wood or rubber and is considered more substantial than the LCR's. This can provide better control and comfort for users with larger hands.
5. Price:
Prices fluctuate, but generally, the Ruger LCR is slightly more affordable than the Smith & Wesson 642. This price difference is often attributed to the LCR’s less expensive materials (polymer vs. steel).
Which Revolver is Right for You?
The "best" revolver depends entirely on your individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Ruger LCR if:
- Concealed carry is your priority: Its lightweight design makes it ideal for all-day carry.
- Budget is a concern: The LCR generally comes with a lower price tag.
- You prioritize a firm grip: The rubber grip provides excellent traction.
Choose the Smith & Wesson 642 if:
- Recoil management is crucial: The heavier weight minimizes felt recoil.
- You prefer a smoother trigger pull: The 642 often features a lighter, more comfortable trigger.
- You value a more substantial grip: Its larger grip may be more comfortable for those with larger hands.
Ultimately, the best way to decide is to handle both revolvers and shoot them if possible. Consider the factors discussed above, and choose the one that feels most comfortable and controllable in your hands. Remember to always prioritize safety and proper training regardless of your chosen firearm.
