Choosing between the Benelli Supernova and the Mossberg 590 is a common dilemma for shotgun enthusiasts. Both are renowned for their reliability and performance, but they cater to different needs and preferences. This in-depth comparison will help you determine which shotgun reigns supreme for your specific requirements.
Reliability and Durability: Built to Last
Both the Benelli Supernova and the Mossberg 590 are built like tanks, renowned for their unwavering reliability even under harsh conditions. The Supernova, with its inertia-driven operating system, boasts exceptionally smooth cycling, handling even light loads with ease. This system, however, does require a bit more precision in cleaning and maintenance. The Mossberg 590, operating on a tried-and-true pump-action system, offers legendary simplicity and robustness. Its straightforward design translates to easy cleaning, maintenance, and fewer potential points of failure. Both shotguns are built to withstand years of heavy use, making the choice here largely dependent on personal preference regarding operating systems and maintenance routines.
Ergonomics and Handling: Comfort and Control
The ergonomics of each shotgun significantly impact shooting experience. The Benelli Supernova stands out with its innovative adjustable stock and comb, allowing for a highly customizable fit. This is a significant advantage for shooters of varying sizes and builds, ensuring optimal comfort and a consistent cheek weld. The pistol grip also contributes to improved control and maneuverability. The Mossberg 590, while offering fewer adjustment options, is generally praised for its comfortable grip and well-balanced design. Its relatively lighter weight, compared to the Supernova, makes it easier to handle during extended shooting sessions. Ultimately, the "better" ergonomics depend heavily on the individual shooter's physique and preferences.
Stock and Forend Differences: A Closer Look
The Benelli Supernova's adjustable stock is a game-changer for shooters who prioritize a customized fit. This feature significantly impacts accuracy and comfort, especially during prolonged shooting sessions. The Supernova's forend is also generally considered more ergonomic for faster pump action.
The Mossberg 590’s stock is more traditional and less customizable, but its simplicity often appeals to users. The forend, while functional, might feel less ergonomic to some shooters when compared to the Benelli's design.
Features and Accessories: Expanding Capabilities
Both shotguns boast a wide array of aftermarket accessories, allowing for significant customization. However, the Mossberg 590 enjoys a slightly larger and more established aftermarket support, offering a broader range of stocks, barrels, and tactical accessories. Both shotguns can be equipped with tactical lights, slings, and other accessories to enhance their functionality for specific applications. The availability of accessories should only play a minor role in your decision unless you're planning extensive modifications.
Price and Value: Getting the Most for Your Money
Price is a significant factor for many buyers. Generally, the Mossberg 590 is more budget-friendly than the Benelli Supernova. This doesn't necessarily translate to inferior quality; rather, it reflects differences in manufacturing processes and materials. The Supernova's higher price point reflects its more advanced features like the adjustable stock and inertia-driven system. The value proposition depends on the individual's budget and priorities.
Conclusion: The Verdict
There is no single "winner" in the Benelli Supernova vs. Mossberg 590 debate. The ideal choice depends entirely on your individual needs, preferences, and budget.
-
Choose the Benelli Supernova if: You prioritize an adjustable stock for a perfect fit, a smooth inertia-driven system, and are willing to pay a premium for advanced features.
-
Choose the Mossberg 590 if: You prefer a simpler, more robust pump-action system, a more budget-friendly option, and a wider selection of readily available aftermarket accessories.
Careful consideration of these factors will help you make an informed decision and select the shotgun that best suits your specific shooting style and requirements. Remember to handle both shotguns if possible before making a purchase to get a feel for their ergonomics and overall handling.
